Sunday morning, I accepted an invitation to join a friend for a class in a 3 part series with our rabbi about parenting- Jewish style. How Yids Raise Kids. I’m pretty sure that’s not actually the name of the series. This morning’s theme was “Talking to your children about God”. A bit heavy at 9:15AM on a Sunday morning after the previous night’s dinner with friends which lasted until way-late o’clock. It was a rainy morning outside my house and a very foggy morning inside my head. At the end of the session, I can confidently report that I had no idea how to talk about God, God help me.
It’s not the rabbi’s fault that I did not leave with answers. I walked away realizing that I need to sort it out in my mind first before I can come up with God-Lite for my kids. Problem is, the older I get, the less I believe in God. That might not make me very popular, but if there’s a God, he, she or it forgives my doubt and respects my struggle. If it helps you sleep at night, you may pray for my eternal soul though I do believe there are many other souls in need of more urgent prayer.
So where does that leave this Jewish mom who is doing her best to provide a Jewish foundation and community for her kids? And what am I doing leading the family service on Shabbat for chrissake?
The rabbi guided us as best she could. We all agreed that God doesn’t have to be an old, bearded man controlling the world from his throne. Perhaps God is a force- intangible and greater than we are. My little brain hurts. Where are the bagels? What kind of God-loving synagogue offers a class at the crack of ass on a Sunday and doesn’t serve bagels? Clearly, there’s no God here. Every now and then when conversation turned to static haze, my mind wandered as I imagined the conversations yet to come.
“Mom, is there a God?” “What? Is your room clean!?”
“Mom, do you talk to God?” “Absolutely! I say, ‘God, keep my kids away from drugs, whores and reality television producers!’”
“Mom, can I be Jewish if I don’t believe in God?” “No! If they find out you don’t believe in God, they glue your foreskin back on with cement and you can never order Chinese food again!”
Um, NOT! I’m working on it. You’ll have to take my word for it that I do have a few slightly more thoughtful answers up my sleeve. The good news is that the Judaism to which I subscribe allows for a little artistic license when it comes to God. Love, nature, goodness in humankind, to name a few more abstract concepts of the The Lord our God, Ruler of the Universe. Still, God is a tough pill for me to swallow-whether it’s a dissolvable tablet or gel-coated capsule. No matter how it’s packaged, I can’t quite find the concept that works for me.
I came home from the session and played with the boys. They were both particularly cute, and I marvelled for a bit. Levi stomped around the house with a hat-sized cardboard box on his head for hours and pretended to be a Pirasaur. Apparently, that would be a dinosaur that says “Aaaaargh!” while winking his eye, matey! Asher insisted I capture a medley of song on the camera which reminded me that kids can commit many songs to memory without ever really understanding the words. I couldn’t bring myself to review the actual words for Baa Baa Black Sheep. I agree that sheep have a tendency to go on and on.
Video attached in case you are reading in an email. Go to blog to view.
During moments like these, emotion and awe swell inside until I’m shooting love beams out of every pore. Is that God? Some say love IS God. Some say love, it is a flower...
I don’t have to completely turn my back on my tribe because there’s so much more to being Jewish than the God part. But just in case anyone does threaten to confiscate all my Chinese food menus, I’ve done a little research. I’ve discovered the Belief-O-Matic Quiz that you can take HERE. Answer a few questions, and the major religions will be ranked for you based on your thoughts about religion and God. Turns out, I’d feel quite at home as a Secular Humanitarian, a Universal Unitarian or a Liberal Quaker but not so much as a Jehovah’s Witness. Reform Judaism made it into the top 10, and I can live with that. Care to share your results?
The theme of our next session is all about talking to kids about death. That should be a laugh-riot. I’d better pick up a bagel before I get there. Don’t want to spend my morning depressed AND hungry.
Monday, May 4, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)








9 comments:
"Blah-blah black sheep!" Hysterically cute! Reminds me of when our Asher used to sing "Asher Asher all fall down" in ring around the rosie. Priceless...
God is a tough topic - I think we have taken the approach to toe the Jewish party line for now with Torah stories, etc to get the "basics" down but as far as God is concerned, we have described him as being all around us, and not necessarily a person but a state of mind. The Torah stories (et al.) really work for Asher because they usually involve a Jewish hero (David, Moses, Judah Maccabee) and he seems to really like that!
Have you read that Blessing of a Skinned Knee book? It's been a while but I really enjoyed that one. Never easy...
Wish you'd mentioned the bagels. They were RIGHT BEHIND YOU! Coffee and tea, too. Probably some egg salad. There's always food at that place! Were I not on restrictions you would have noticed my plate piled HIGH (maybe twice).
Take notes on death for me. Which reminds me, we drove past a semmetary last night and Hannah said, "Look! Dead signs!"
cemetery. what's wrong with me?
Asher is adorable! Blah blah black sheep had me laughing out loud. Who is Ruby though? Why did she too lose her lamb?
I took the belief o matic thing and it came back "Heathen". Just kidding...Secular Humanism. Seems about right.
Hi, there. Wow. HUGE topic, and as usual, you bring together the everyday and the philosophically expansive deftly and with a sense of humor.
First of all, Asher is exactly right in guessing the it's "Bla Bla Black sheep..." It certainly has more poetic logic -- someone's havign a tough time pronouncing the whole word(than does "ba").
As for God, I had often thought about what I would say to my hypothetical children on the topic. Atheism and agnosticism themselves are after all faith systems. I don't know how well "Some people think... while others..." would go over with little kids; too much comparative religion and relativism too soon? ;-)
But I agree with you, D, IF there is a divinity of some sort, that supreme being/consciousness will not hold our having doubts or even disbelief in particular narratives against us.
As for the beliefomatic thing, I had taken this test ages ago, came out a quaker first and secular humanist second (and my own religious tradition was one of the last things I am according to the test), but my gf told me that would never work for me as Quakers don't talk very much.
And how could I forget: ASHER IS AMAZINGLY CUTE!!!
And then, of course, there will be the "Talking to your kids about Israel/Palestine" session and some heads just might explode.
I found you via Vikki at Up Popped a Fox, and I'm very pleased about that -- us Jewish dyke moms need to stick together and all.
skinned knee-must read. great tip!
i missed the bagels? CRAP! won't let THAT happen again!!
ruby was the lamb's first owner, but her father was a butcher. the lamb grew suspicious of all his disappearing flock-friends and high-tailed (!) it over to mary's. mary was taking in lost sheep...and providing them with a good education (thus following her to school) so that they could find jobs and lead productive lives.
and i'll report back on where asher really got ruby as i'm all blah-blah-blah.
timp, let the quakers speak in hush tones. you shall never be silenced as you have far too much wisdom to share. (thank you)
welcome Mama!! many thanks to our yenta, vikki, for the set up. god does seem an easier conversation than israel/palestine. that'll be a hoot. when my doctor father tried to explain reproduction to me, he used a lot of big words and illustrations of internal organs until i was confused and bored. i'm thinking this was a good approach for starters.
Finally catching up *again* and am in hysterics over "blah, blah, black sheep"! (Side note - were you an "Arrested Development" fan? Best TV character name EVER: Bob Loblaw, played by Scott Baio.)
And yeah, Ruby? That's a new one to me. Good for Asher to give her some credit.
I second the rec for "Blessing of a Skinned Knee" - I started it months ago and have a long way to go, but it is really wonderful.
As for death, my niece had the most wonderful explanation (at age 4-1/2) for what happens when you die. This came up when my sister and b-i-l had to put their dog down, and were mulling over how to explain that he wouldn't be coming back from the vet with them. She told her parents that when you die, you just get smaller and smaller until you disappear. Isn't that just incredible?
Thanks for continuing to do what you do, DG. Miss you, and hope to catch up more soon!
blah blah black sheep! excellent.
Post a Comment